Victory Patterns’ Simone dress: not worth it!

Victory Patterns Simone muslin - front

Last week I mentioned that I was playing around with Victory PatternsSimone dress and trying to overcome some challenges in the pattern.  Well folks, I have officially given up… for now at least.  Maybe I’ll come back to this one day when I can muster up the patience for some serious pattern alterations, but for now I’ve had enough frustration.

First of all, the instructions that come with the pattern are awful, so much so that I actually feel embarrassed for Kristiann that she let this crap pass through whatever form of quality control they have.  In fact, I suspect there was no quality control at all, as anyone reading the instructions would have immediately caught some glaring errors.  I’m not just talking about typos here – there are portions of the instructions that make no sense at all, particularly for the front placket insertion.  This is not indie patternmaking at its best.  My advice: do NOT buy this pattern.

Despite the poor instructions, I tried my best to make it work.  You can see my muslin above, featuring a handful of design alterations to try to turn the dress into exactly what I had in mind.  Most notably, I didn’t like the pleats in the front and the resulting fullness in the silhouette – it made me feel like I was wearing a tent.  So, I stitched them down all the way down to the hem.  In theory I like the effect, but it resulted in some strain under the bust.

Victory Patterns Simone muslin - front detail

You can really see it in the photo above – see how the pleats are pulling the fabric too far in?  Not a good look, but I also didn’t want to go back to the original pleating and muumuu-like effect.

My other major issue with this dress was that I couldn’t get the front placket and neckline slit to lay flat, even before I sewed down the pleats.  The whole area looked too tortured and overworked, and this is supposed to be the highlight of the dress.  I suspect my upper bust is too wide for the pattern, which is the case for most patterns.  However, it looks like this area is tight and/or tortured for most of the Simone’s I’ve seen on the web… and even on the pattern model!  I don’t think it’s just me; I think it’s a drafting issue.

I bet if I had the patience I could fix these issues, and maybe one day I’ll give it a try, but I decided that a complete pattern overhaul at this point wasn’t worth it.  Too bad, because I do like the aesthetic of the dress.

Victory Patterns Simone muslin - side

In fact, I really like the side view.  This is exactly the silhouette I was hoping for when I bought the pattern.  (Note that I had already sewn down the front pleats here; otherwise there was way too much fullness in the front for my taste.)

Victory Patterns Simone muslin - backI also like the back view… kind of.  (BTW, please excuse my striped undergarments here!  Clearly a lining would be needed in a light colored fabric.)  The racerback looks great and fit well after I let out the shoulder seams by 1/2 inch to accommodate my height.

But, see how all the fullness in the back skirt is hanging out right in the center?  This is after I removed a whopping 10-inch wedge from the center back – you should have seen it beforehand!  Excuse my language here, but I think it looks like a huge butt crack going all the way down to the floor.  Not a good look!!  Annoyingly, the pattern photo doesn’t show this “feature,” and instead the fullness is evenly distributed across the back.  Can anyone say bait and switch?

Here’s why this is happening: the back skirt piece, which fits into the V-shaped bottom of the racerback, is NOT cut to match the racerback.  Instead, in order to make the skirt fit, you have to spread apart the two halves of the V, thereby pushing all the fullness of the skirt toward the center.  In my opinion, this is simply poor pattern drafting.  Why not just cut it to match?

Anyway, I don’t enjoy giving poor reviews, and I’m sure Kristiann is a perfectly wonderful person.  However, I think blogs are a good vehicle for honest product feedback, so that’s what I’m offering here.  I fully acknowledge that my attempted design alterations caused some of the fitting issues, but not all of them.  And aside from the fit/drafting issues, the instructions are inexcusable.  Especially with a $20 (US) pricetag!

But never fear, my quest for a floaty summer maxi dress is not over… I spent the weekend drafting my own!  More to come on that soon.  🙂

 

Advertisements

18 thoughts on “Victory Patterns’ Simone dress: not worth it!

    • I feel the same way – I can see the foundation of a fun summer dress here, but it seems like way too much work to get the fit right. At least I gave it the old college try!

    • It definitely bothers me when people do that – glossing over issues and praising the pattern when clearly things were a little off. Hopefully my brutal honesty will help potential buyers!

  1. Well crap. I love the finished look, it’s so cute as a shirt, maybe it won’t look so butt-cracky as a shirt. I need more shirts!

    I agree with Annette though, I would have balled that up in shoved it in a corner probably almost right away. Hopefully someday you’ll get it to work. Nothing is more frustrating than spending so much time trying to make something work when it just won’t.

    • Agreed, it just wasn’t worth any more of my time! I’d be curious to see more Simone shirts on the web, but I still say that it’ll be tough getting the front placket to lay properly. There are plenty of better shirt patterns out there!

  2. Thanks for the honest review. I was really on the fence about this pattern. I love the style, but the fit always seems a bit off on everyone. And one of the main reasons I buy indie patterns is for the amazing instructions – that’s what justifies the price for me – so that’s really disappointing that they’re so bad. I can’t wait to see what what you’ve drafted!

    • Thanks – I was trying to justify the $20 I had spent on the pattern and put in the effort to make it work, but it was way too frustrating in the end. I did learn a lesson for my $20 though – how to recognize drafting issues. I guess it was a good learning experience. 🙂

    • Well said. If you’re a total beginner, I think it’s reasonable to doubt your skills and trust a professionally-produced pattern. I’m clearly not an expert at this point in my sewing career, but I think I have enough experience and enough successful garments to say that it wasn’t 100% user error.

    • I totally agree. For any type of product, sewing patterns included, a high price should come with high quality. There are certainly some good things about this pattern (I still love the style!), but the technical issues should have been worked out before it went up for sale.

    • Glad you found this post useful, Lisa. I have yet to see a Simone that looks like it fits well across the bust, but who knows, someone may surprise me one day!

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s